PUNDITS.
College football · 2026–27

College football Week 5

Tracked Week 5 record: 35–26 on 61 graded picks. Florida at Missouri: Missouri beat Florida. Chris "The Bear" Fallica called Missouri. Chip Patterson, David Pollack, Desmond Howard, Joel Klatt, Kirk Herbstreit, Nick Saban, Pat McAfee, Tom Fornelli, and Will Compton picked Florida. Ohio State at Iowa: Ohio State beat Iowa. Chris "The Bear" Fallica, David Pollack, Joel Klatt, Josh Pate, Kirk Herbstreit, Nick Saban, and Pat McAfee called Ohio State. Desmond Howard picked Iowa. Auburn at Tennessee: Tennessee beat Auburn. David Pollack called Tennessee. Chris "The Bear" Fallica picked Auburn. Maryland at Nebraska: Nebraska beat Maryland. Clay Travis called Nebraska. Bud Elliott picked Maryland. Washington at USC: USC beat Washington. David Pollack, Desmond Howard, Joel Klatt, Nick Saban, and Pat McAfee called USC. Chip Patterson and Kirk Herbstreit picked Washington. Cincinnati at Arizona: Arizona beat Cincinnati. Danny Kanell, Desmond Howard, and Nick Saban called Arizona. Chip Patterson, David Pollack, Kirk Herbstreit, and Pat McAfee picked Cincinnati.

This is the tracked subset on Pundits.Pro, not a survey of all experts.

Verified disagreements

  1. Florida at Missouri — Missouri beat Florida. Chris "The Bear" Fallica called Missouri. Chip Patterson, David Pollack, Desmond Howard, Joel Klatt, Kirk Herbstreit, Nick Saban, Pat McAfee, Tom Fornelli, and Will Compton picked Florida.
  2. Ohio State at Iowa — Ohio State beat Iowa. Chris "The Bear" Fallica, David Pollack, Joel Klatt, Josh Pate, Kirk Herbstreit, Nick Saban, and Pat McAfee called Ohio State. Desmond Howard picked Iowa.
  3. Auburn at Tennessee — Tennessee beat Auburn. David Pollack called Tennessee. Chris "The Bear" Fallica picked Auburn.
  4. Maryland at Nebraska — Nebraska beat Maryland. Clay Travis called Nebraska. Bud Elliott picked Maryland.
  5. Washington at USC — USC beat Washington. David Pollack, Desmond Howard, Joel Klatt, Nick Saban, and Pat McAfee called USC. Chip Patterson and Kirk Herbstreit picked Washington.
  6. Cincinnati at Arizona — Arizona beat Cincinnati. Danny Kanell, Desmond Howard, and Nick Saban called Arizona. Chip Patterson, David Pollack, Kirk Herbstreit, and Pat McAfee picked Cincinnati.

Graded picks

  1. Bud Elliott— hit (Bowling Green over Miami (OH), 20¢)
  2. Bud Elliott— hit (San Diego State over Texas State, 24¢)
  3. Chris "The Bear" Fallica— hit (Ohio State over Iowa, 85¢)
  4. Chris "The Bear" Fallica— hit (Missouri over Florida, 34¢)
  5. Chris "The Bear" Fallica— hit (Texas A&M over Arkansas, 84¢)
  6. Chris "The Bear" Fallica— hit (Miami over Clemson, 87¢)
  7. Clay Travis— hit (Nebraska over Maryland, 86¢)
  8. Danny Kanell— hit (Florida State over Virginia, 49¢)
  9. Danny Kanell— hit (Arizona over Cincinnati, 69¢)
  10. David Pollack— hit (Ohio State over Iowa, 85¢)
  11. David Pollack— hit (Tennessee over Auburn, 70¢)
  12. David Pollack— hit (USC over Washington, 77¢)
  13. Desmond Howard— hit (BYU over TCU, 68¢)
  14. Desmond Howard— hit (Miami over Clemson, 87¢)
  15. Desmond Howard— hit (USC over Washington, 77¢)
  16. Desmond Howard— hit (Arizona over Cincinnati, 69¢)
  17. Joel Klatt— hit (Ohio State over Iowa, 85¢)
  18. Joel Klatt— hit (Miami over Clemson, 87¢)
  19. Joel Klatt— hit (USC over Washington, 77¢)
  20. Josh Pate— hit (Ohio State over Iowa, 85¢)
  21. Josh Pate— hit (Miami over Clemson, 87¢)
  22. Josh Pate— hit (Indiana over Rutgers, 94¢)
  23. Kirk Herbstreit— hit (Ohio State over Iowa, 85¢)
  24. Kirk Herbstreit— hit (BYU over TCU, 68¢)
  25. Nick Saban— hit (Ohio State over Iowa, 85¢)
  26. Nick Saban— hit (BYU over TCU, 68¢)
  27. Nick Saban— hit (Miami over Clemson, 87¢)
  28. Nick Saban— hit (USC over Washington, 77¢)
  29. Nick Saban— hit (Arizona over Cincinnati, 69¢)
  30. Pat McAfee— hit (Ohio State over Iowa, 85¢)
  31. Pat McAfee— hit (BYU over TCU, 68¢)
  32. Pat McAfee— hit (Miami over Clemson, 87¢)
  33. Pat McAfee— hit (USC over Washington, 77¢)
  34. Tom Fornelli— hit (Purdue over Illinois, 23¢)
  35. Will Compton— hit (Miami over Clemson, 87¢)
  36. Bud Elliott— miss (California over UNLV, 49¢)
  37. Bud Elliott— miss (Maryland over Nebraska, 15¢)
  38. Bud Elliott— miss (Rice over UTSA, 20¢)
  39. Bud Elliott— miss (Coastal Carolina over Georgia Southern, 46¢)
  40. Chip Patterson— miss (Florida over Missouri, 67¢)
  41. Chip Patterson— miss (Washington over USC, 25¢)
  42. Chip Patterson— miss (Cincinnati over Arizona, 31¢)
  43. Chris "The Bear" Fallica— miss (Auburn over Tennessee, 31¢)
  44. Danny Kanell— miss (California over UNLV, 49¢)
  45. David Pollack— miss (Florida over Missouri, 67¢)
  46. David Pollack— miss (Cincinnati over Arizona, 31¢)
  47. Desmond Howard— miss (Iowa over Ohio State, 15¢)
  48. Desmond Howard— miss (Florida over Missouri, 67¢)
  49. Desmond Howard— miss (UMass over Eastern Michigan, 67¢)
  50. Joel Klatt— miss (Florida over Missouri, 67¢)
  51. Kirk Herbstreit— miss (Florida over Missouri, 67¢)
  52. Kirk Herbstreit— miss (UMass over Eastern Michigan, 67¢)
  53. Kirk Herbstreit— miss (Washington over USC, 25¢)
  54. Kirk Herbstreit— miss (Cincinnati over Arizona, 31¢)
  55. Nick Saban— miss (Florida over Missouri, 67¢)
  56. Nick Saban— miss (UMass over Eastern Michigan, 67¢)
  57. Pat McAfee— miss (Florida over Missouri, 67¢)
  58. Pat McAfee— miss (UMass over Eastern Michigan, 67¢)
  59. Pat McAfee— miss (Cincinnati over Arizona, 31¢)
  60. Tom Fornelli— miss (Florida over Missouri, 67¢)
  61. Will Compton— miss (Florida over Missouri, 67¢)