Expert picks
Who’s picking
what.
College football and NFL picks from named analysts and commentators.
These are public comments from named experts, not bets they placed. The number is a dated Kalshi snapshot, not a live sportsbook line. Open a card for the evidence and source. After the game we mark who was right, straight up. An empty side means no verified pick has been captured yet.
This week
College football
Week 7 · Oct 17 · Week 6 is final
Week 7: experts went 2–1. Andy Staples and Ari Wasserman hit on Miami.
Up next
NFL
Week 5 · Oct 11–12 · Week 4 is final
Swipe for more
Kalshi
Indiana wins the national title
Takes it9¢
Thamel
Against91¢
Finebaum · Herbstreit
Kalshi
Texas wins the SEC
Takes it21¢
Finebaum
Against79¢
Davis
Kalshi
Texas makes the Playoff
Takes it63¢
Herbstreit
Against37¢
Fallica
Kalshi
Rams win the Super Bowl
Takes it16¢
Butler · Orlovsky
Against84¢
Hawk
Kalshi
Bills win the Super Bowl
Takes it8¢
Bayless · Hawk
Against92¢
No pick yet
Takes · quote feed
Latest verified picks
Swipe for more
Pick story
A.J. Hawk picked Rams over Bills — and missed (Bills won)
The Pat McAfee Show — PMS 2.0 1643 Overreaction Monday, MNF Preview/Picks · 2026-10-12
Pick story
Andy Staples picked Miami over Florida State — and hit
Andy & Ari On3 — PICKING College Football Week 7 · 2026-10-12
Pick story
Andy Staples picked Notre Dame over BYU — and missed (BYU won)
Andy & Ari On3 — PICKING College Football Week 7 · 2026-10-12
Pick story
Ari Wasserman picked Miami over Florida State — and hit
Andy & Ari On3 — PICKING College Football Week 7 · 2026-10-12
Pick story
Dan Orlovsky picked Rams over Bills — and missed (Bills won)
First Take — Hour 2: Which NFC East team has been the most Disappointing? · 2026-10-12
Pick story
Darius Butler picked Rams over Bills — and missed (Bills won)
The Pat McAfee Show — PMS 2.0 1643 Overreaction Monday, MNF Preview/Picks · 2026-10-12
Pick story
Jason McIntyre picked Rams over Bills — and missed (Bills won)
Straight Fire with Jason McIntyre (FOX Sports Radio) — 49ers Peaking Too Early, Sirianni Hot Seat · 2026-10-12
Pick story
Pat McAfee picked Rams over Bills — and missed (Bills won)
The Pat McAfee Show — PMS 2.0 1643 Overreaction Monday, MNF Preview/Picks · 2026-10-12
Most on record
The table
Swipe for more
The Book · compact ledger
Fresh quotes
Swipe for more
“I think the Rams win in cover.”
McIntyre
Straight Fire with Jason McIntyre (FOX Sports Radio) — 49ers Peaking Too Early, Sirianni Hot Seat
“I'm not gonna waffle. I definitely still am taking the Rams. I think they win by seven, but I love this Bills team.”
Hawk
The Pat McAfee Show — PMS 2.0 1643 Overreaction Monday, MNF Preview/Picks
“I'm going to stick with my Rams pick … So I'm going with the Rams.”
Butler
The Pat McAfee Show — PMS 2.0 1643 Overreaction Monday, MNF Preview/Picks
“I like the Rams.”
McAfee
The Pat McAfee Show — PMS 2.0 1643 Overreaction Monday, MNF Preview/Picks
“Yeah, I'm gonna take the Rams.”
Orlovsky
First Take — Hour 2: Which NFC East team has been the most Disappointing?
“So I'm taking Miami here. I'm done, you know, putting any hope or thought into Florida State being, you know, somewhat good.”
Wasserman
Andy & Ari On3 — PICKING College Football Week 7
PICK ALERTS · EARLY ACCESS
Get new picks — with the receipt.
Join the early list for email alerts when new pundit picks are published. Alerts are not live yet.