PUNDITS.
NFL · 2026–27

NFL Week 5

Tracked Week 5 record: 33–34 on 67 graded picks. Browns at Jets: Jets beat Browns. Chris Simms called Jets. Clay Travis, Mike Florio, and Mina Kimes picked Browns. Giants at Commanders: Giants and Commanders tied 27–27. Every pick on this game graded a push. Vikings at Saints: Vikings beat Saints. A.J. Hawk, Mike Florio, and Mina Kimes called Vikings. Chris Simms picked Saints. Raiders at Patriots: Patriots beat Raiders. Chris Simms and Mike Florio called Patriots. Mina Kimes picked Raiders. 49ers at Seahawks: 49ers beat Seahawks. Colin Cowherd, Kyle Brandt, and Mina Kimes called 49ers. A.J. Hawk, Chris Simms, Mike Florio, Nick Wright, and Stanford Steve Coughlin picked Seahawks. Lions at Cardinals: Lions beat Cardinals. Jason McIntyre and Mike Florio called Lions. Chris Simms picked Cardinals. Bills at Rams: Bills beat Rams. John Middlekauff called Bills. A.J. Hawk, Chris Simms, Colin Cowherd, Dan Orlovsky, Darius Butler, Jason McIntyre, Kyle Brandt, Mike Florio, Nick Wright, and Pat McAfee picked Rams.

This is the tracked subset on Pundits.Pro, not a survey of all experts.

Verified disagreements

  1. Browns at Jets — Jets beat Browns. Chris Simms called Jets. Clay Travis, Mike Florio, and Mina Kimes picked Browns.
  2. Giants at Commanders — Giants and Commanders tied 27–27. Every pick on this game graded a push.
  3. Vikings at Saints — Vikings beat Saints. A.J. Hawk, Mike Florio, and Mina Kimes called Vikings. Chris Simms picked Saints.
  4. Raiders at Patriots — Patriots beat Raiders. Chris Simms and Mike Florio called Patriots. Mina Kimes picked Raiders.
  5. 49ers at Seahawks — 49ers beat Seahawks. Colin Cowherd, Kyle Brandt, and Mina Kimes called 49ers. A.J. Hawk, Chris Simms, Mike Florio, Nick Wright, and Stanford Steve Coughlin picked Seahawks.
  6. Lions at Cardinals — Lions beat Cardinals. Jason McIntyre and Mike Florio called Lions. Chris Simms picked Cardinals.
  7. Bills at Rams — Bills beat Rams. John Middlekauff called Bills. A.J. Hawk, Chris Simms, Colin Cowherd, Dan Orlovsky, Darius Butler, Jason McIntyre, Kyle Brandt, Mike Florio, Nick Wright, and Pat McAfee picked Rams.

Graded picks

  1. A.J. Hawk— hit (Vikings over Saints, 56¢)
  2. A.J. Hawk— hit (Jaguars over Eagles, 77¢)
  3. Chris Simms— hit (Steelers over Colts, 59¢)
  4. Chris Simms— hit (Jets over Browns, 56¢)
  5. Chris Simms— hit (Bengals over Dolphins, 76¢)
  6. Chris Simms— hit (Broncos over Chargers, 64¢)
  7. Chris Simms— hit (Patriots over Raiders, 63¢)
  8. Colin Cowherd— hit (Steelers over Colts, 59¢)
  9. Colin Cowherd— hit (49ers over Seahawks, 39¢)
  10. Jason McIntyre— hit (Texans over Titans, 77¢)
  11. Jason McIntyre— hit (Steelers over Colts, 59¢)
  12. Jason McIntyre— hit (Broncos over Chargers, 64¢)
  13. Jason McIntyre— hit (Bengals over Dolphins, 76¢)
  14. Jason McIntyre— hit (Lions over Cardinals, 70¢)
  15. John Middlekauff— hit (Jaguars over Eagles, 77¢)
  16. John Middlekauff— hit (Bills over Rams, 39¢)
  17. Kyle Brandt— hit (49ers over Seahawks, 39¢)
  18. Mike Florio— hit (Bengals over Dolphins, 76¢)
  19. Mike Florio— hit (Patriots over Raiders, 63¢)
  20. Mike Florio— hit (Vikings over Saints, 56¢)
  21. Mike Florio— hit (Steelers over Colts, 59¢)
  22. Mike Florio— hit (Texans over Titans, 77¢)
  23. Mike Florio— hit (Broncos over Chargers, 64¢)
  24. Mike Florio— hit (Lions over Cardinals, 70¢)
  25. Mina Kimes— hit (Bengals over Dolphins, 76¢)
  26. Mina Kimes— hit (Steelers over Colts, 59¢)
  27. Mina Kimes— hit (Texans over Titans, 77¢)
  28. Mina Kimes— hit (Broncos over Chargers, 64¢)
  29. Mina Kimes— hit (49ers over Seahawks, 39¢)
  30. Mina Kimes— hit (Vikings over Saints, 56¢)
  31. Nick Wright— hit (Texans over Titans, 77¢)
  32. Sheil Kapadia— hit (Texans over Titans, 77¢)
  33. Stanford Steve Coughlin— hit (Jaguars over Eagles, 77¢)
  34. A.J. Hawk— miss (Seahawks over 49ers, 62¢)
  35. A.J. Hawk— miss (Falcons over Ravens, 62¢)
  36. A.J. Hawk— miss (Rams over Bills, 62¢)
  37. Bill Simmons— miss (Bears over Packers, 59¢)
  38. Chris Simms— miss (Bears over Packers, 59¢)
  39. Chris Simms— miss (Saints over Vikings, 44¢)
  40. Chris Simms— miss (Seahawks over 49ers, 62¢)
  41. Chris Simms— miss (Falcons over Ravens, 62¢)
  42. Chris Simms— miss (Rams over Bills, 62¢)
  43. Chris Simms— miss (Cardinals over Lions, 31¢)
  44. Clay Travis— miss (Browns over Jets, 45¢)
  45. Clay Travis— miss (Falcons over Ravens, 62¢)
  46. Colin Cowherd— miss (Bears over Packers, 59¢)
  47. Colin Cowherd— miss (Rams over Bills, 62¢)
  48. Dan Orlovsky— miss (Rams over Bills, 62¢)
  49. Darius Butler— miss (Rams over Bills, 62¢)
  50. Jason McIntyre— miss (Bears over Packers, 59¢)
  51. Jason McIntyre— miss (Rams over Bills, 62¢)
  52. John Middlekauff— miss (Bears over Packers, 59¢)
  53. Kyle Brandt— miss (Rams over Bills, 62¢)
  54. Mike Florio— miss (Bears over Packers, 59¢)
  55. Mike Florio— miss (Browns over Jets, 45¢)
  56. Mike Florio— miss (Seahawks over 49ers, 62¢)
  57. Mike Florio— miss (Falcons over Ravens, 62¢)
  58. Mike Florio— miss (Rams over Bills, 62¢)
  59. Mina Kimes— miss (Browns over Jets, 45¢)
  60. Mina Kimes— miss (Raiders over Patriots, 38¢)
  61. Mina Kimes— miss (Falcons over Ravens, 62¢)
  62. Mina Kimes— miss (Bears over Packers, 59¢)
  63. Nick Wright— miss (Seahawks over 49ers, 62¢)
  64. Nick Wright— miss (Rams over Bills, 62¢)
  65. Pat McAfee— miss (Rams over Bills, 62¢)
  66. Stanford Steve Coughlin— miss (Seahawks over 49ers, 62¢)
  67. Stanford Steve Coughlin— miss (Falcons over Ravens, 62¢)