PUNDITS.
Take · ✗ Miss

Kirk Herbstreit picked Virginia over West Virginia — and missed (West Virginia won)

Published by Pundits.Pro · Source published Sep 19, 2026 · On Pundits Sep 20, 2026 · Graded Sep 20, 2026

Receipt · Cole's GameDay Blog Week 3 · Sep 19, 2026 · Reported selection
Miss

Virginia over West Virginia

Kirk Herbstreit
Kirk Herbstreit
College GameDay
Snapshot West Virginia 23¢ (≈ +335) / Virginia 77¢ (≈ -335) · as of Sep 20, 2026
Final West Virginia 38, Virginia 27 · Graded Sep 20, 2026

This published receipt is under evidence review. The original recorded label is preserved. We are seeking the original clip or transcript and will not invent spoken wording.

The displayed number is a dated event-level Kalshi snapshot, not live odds and not necessarily the market when the original prediction was spoken or first captured.

Desmond Howard and Nick Saban also picked Virginia. Pat McAfee picked West Virginia. The full split is on the game page.

Result
West Virginia won 38–27.
Grading
The tracked result is the straight-up winner, not a spread cover.
Record
Kirk Herbstreit is 13–15 on graded picks this season, with 9 open. Full record →

The matchup

West Virginia vs Virginia. Full game card →

Also on this market